Independent decision guide

Testing your water: start free, then decide

Filtration without a named contaminant is guesswork. The right first step depends on whether you use city water, a private well, or need an answer at one particular tap.

Choose the route that matches the water source

City water: read the utility’s Consumer Confidence Report first. Private well: call the local health department; EPA notes that some departments may offer testing or direct owners to an appropriate certified lab. Lead or one-tap concern: ask the utility or health department for the sampling protocol and certified-lab route that applies locally.

A free or reduced-cost local program may cover only selected contaminants. Ask what is included, how the sample must be collected, and whether the result meets the purpose you have in mind before deciding that no further test is needed.

EPA guidance for well owners

What the EPA says to test for

For a private well, the EPA recommends testing annually for four things — and testing more often if small children or elderly adults live in the house, or if someone is pregnant or nursing. It also advises using only laboratories certified to do drinking water testing.

Total coliform bacteria
Nitrates
Total dissolved solids
pH

If you suspect something beyond these — lead, pesticides, volatile organics — the EPA says to test for those too. Choose a paid panel only when it covers the named local or household concern and uses a laboratory whose certification fits the purpose.

If you do need a paid kit

We looked at Tap Score because its certification claims are specific and checkable rather than vague. Here is what its own documentation supports, and what it does not.

What the sources support

  • Tap Score states it uses "ISO 17025, ELAP, and NELAC certified labs only", and that all labs in the SimpleLab network are certified to ISO/IEC 17025. Tap Score official site
  • Tap Score states most people receive results within 3–5 business days after the lab receives the sample, though individual tests list longer lab windows — the Extended City Water Test shows 12 business days. Tap Score official site
  • Prepaid shipping and sampling materials are stated to be included, with no lab visit required. Tap Score official site
  • The EPA recommends testing a private well annually for total coliform bacteria, nitrates, total dissolved solids, and pH, and advises using only laboratories certified to do drinking water testing. U.S. EPA, Protect Your Home’s Water
  • The EPA notes that a local health department may provide private well testing for free. U.S. EPA, Protect Your Home’s Water

This is a direct editorial link, not a commission link.

A paid lab test may fit if you…

  • draw from a private well, which no Consumer Confidence Report covers;
  • want quantified results from a certified lab rather than a colour-strip estimate;
  • have a specific worry — lead, nitrates, bacteria — that needs a number, not a guess;
  • have already checked whether your health department offers free testing.

Do something else first if you…

  • have not yet called your local health department, which the EPA notes may test private wells for free;
  • are on city water and have not yet read your free Consumer Confidence Report;
  • need a legally defensible result for a property sale, which usually requires a specific state-designated lab;
  • want a rough, immediate reading and accept lower precision, where an inexpensive strip kit may be enough.

Where this leads

Testing is not the goal. Knowing which named contaminants you actually have is the goal, because that is the only thing that makes a filtration decision anything other than a guess.

If you are on city water and have not read your free annual report yet, start there instead — it costs nothing and may answer the question.

Sources

Last reviewed July 25, 2026. Prices and package contents change; confirm before purchasing. Educational information only — not medical advice, and not a water-safety determination for your home.

The lighter-home letter

One problem, one free step, and one honest buying decision each week.

No miracle claims or sales pressure. See our privacy policy.